Order eina með öllu at an Icelandic hot-dog stand and you are asking for one with everything: raw onion, crispy fried onion, ketchup, sweet brown mustard and remoulade.
That sounds like a lot for a small bun, but each topping has a job. The raw onion bites, the fried onion crunches, and the sauces bring sweetness, mustard and a creamy finish. You can leave anything out. Lunch is not an authenticity test.
What comes with “everything”?
| Topping | What it contributes |
|---|---|
| Raw onion | A fresh, sharp bite |
| Crispy fried onion | Crunch beneath the softer ingredients |
| Ketchup | Sweetness and acidity |
| Pylsusinnep | Mild, sweet brown hot-dog mustard |
| Remúlaði | A creamy remoulade-style sauce with relish |
The Icelandic travel-service listing for Bæjarins Beztu confirms that five-part combination. Order and quantity vary between stands, and “everything” should never stand in for an ingredient or allergy check.
The two onions are the part to pay attention to. Take both away and the texture changes more than it would if you dropped a sauce. If you like onion, have the complete version once. If you do not, order the one you will want to finish.
Ordering without a language examination
Eina með öllu means roughly “one with everything,” and English is fine too. Say how many you want and anything to leave off, and have your answer ready by the time you reach the counter.
If ingredients matter to you, ask about the whole order: sausage, bun, sauces and preparation. Do not assume the sausage is pure lamb. SS’s current five-pack, for example, lists sheep, pork and beef, along with milk powder, soy and mustard among its other ingredients. Recipes differ by producer and product. Wheat, milk or egg can turn up elsewhere in the order, and shared equipment may matter.
A shorter queue gives you time to ask, and it says nothing bad about the stand. At a busy counter, settle the ordinary order first, then raise anything essential clearly with the staff.
More than one famous queue
Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur is the Reykjavík stand many visitors have heard of, and you should go if that is part of your trip. Leave room as well for the everyday version at another kiosk or roadside stop, since this food does not belong only to its most photographed counter.
Judge what you get by how fresh and hot it is and how the toppings balance. The length of the queue cannot tell you that. A good hot dog is a small meal you enjoyed, and you do not get extra credit for having stood in the correct place.
Then stop somewhere you can eat it properly. A windy pavement makes a generous line of sauce surprisingly ambitious, and eating in a moving car does neither the food nor the driver a favour.
Making one at home
You need sausages, soft buns, finely chopped raw onion, crispy fried onion and the three sauces. Follow the cooking instructions on the sausage packet and warm the buns without drying them out.
Go easy on the sauce at first so the onions keep some texture. To learn what each topping does, make one with everything and one adjusted to your taste. Flooding the bun will not make it more Icelandic.
Keep the packaging until everyone has checked the ingredients. If you are buying all this during a trip, our grocery guide helps you plan the larger shop around it.
